Maine lawmakers are considering a change to a law passed last year that mandates health care providers collect and record data on the sexual orientation and gender identity of their patients. The new proposal would exempt minors from this requirement, allowing more flexibility in how health providers discuss these sensitive topics.
Rep. Ambureen Rana (D-Bangor), who sponsors the bill (LD 1945), along with medical experts, argues that the adjustment would give health care providers more discretion in addressing concerns about gender and sexual identity with young patients. These conversations, they emphasize, can have significant impacts on a minor’s physical or mental health.
Under the current law, health care providers are required to collect this information from patients at each visit, a practice some find intrusive. Rana believes that this requirement forces discussions that may not be appropriate for all minors, instead of allowing providers to assess when such questions should be broached.
The bill has received support from the Maine Medical Association and the Maine Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, both of which have expressed concern over the mandatory nature of these conversations, especially for minors who may not be ready to discuss their sexual or gender identity.
While the original law sought to empower individuals, particularly those in the LGBTQ+ community, to share their identities without assumptions from providers, health associations argue that such data collection at every visit is unnecessary. They highlight that minors might feel uncomfortable or unsafe discussing their identity in a healthcare setting, potentially skewing the information provided.
Madeleine DesFosses, advocacy and public health manager at the Maine Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, emphasized the importance of safeguarding minors’ privacy and safety. “Requiring health care providers to collect information related to gender identity and sexuality may put a minor in an uncomfortable or confusing position,” she said.
Although the bill would remove the requirement for minors, it does not change the existing provision that allows patients of all ages to decline sharing their gender identity or sexual orientation.
As scrutiny of transgender rights grows across the nation, including in Maine, some lawmakers are pushing for restrictions on gender-affirming care and protections for transgender individuals. The proposed bill offers a counterpoint, seeking to protect the privacy of minors while providing healthcare providers with the flexibility to navigate sensitive topics as appropriate.
Related Topics
